That’s what I was asked, by email. Someone read my previous entry and wanted more details on how a company could truly realize savings on their research and related knowledge work, without a loss of quality.
Here’s a case study based on some client experiences - brace yourself as it’s rather lengthy; if you still have questions at the end of it, just let me know.
Context: Mid-sized consulting company with a corporate library of eight: two sector specialists, five generalists and one researcher for quick turnaround requests. The company is headquartered in New York with five researchers; two others work from a Chicago office and the fifth in LA.
Until Q1 2008 the team was running at full stretch with a small network of local freelancers helping out as needed (Business360 was part of the network), but since Q2 demand started to soften and there was a sharp drop in Q4. With practice (non-billable) work the team is still busy but billability is down to about 60% and still falling.
The company has an internal charge rate of $120/hour for its research services and tries to operate as a profit center, although the reality is they are happy to cover costs.
We’ve been working with the company to look at how they can save money and still deliver a quality service, and (roughly) this is how the numbers stack up. Note: we exclude data costs here which can be large but don’t really affect resourcing decisions.
First you have basic salary costs:
Then for each employee there are a series of direct oncosts (insurance, pension, training etc):
Add these and you arrive at a grand total for annual direct costs of $725,513.
But salaries and related costs aren’t the only ones, there are also indirect corporate overheads, which in this case we just limit to office rental costs:
Note: we use 60 square feet here which is a little tight - most estimates call for ~125ft but the company runs a hot desking approach and believes this amount is all it needs.
Put it all together and you get total costs for each employee:
These costs go to establishing the research services of the company that are charged out on an hourly basis, some for billable purposes and some for non-billable. I mentioned above that billable work for the client’s research team has been falling and this matters since many research teams aim to cover their costs internally and the only way to do this is through internal billing. Research teams do work besides billable assignments but billable work is usually better measured, the value of the work is clearer and for many teams the percent of time billable is the key metric that is tracked. Accordingly, this analysis focuses on the most cost-effective way a research team can complete its billable work.
The amount of hours an employee can be available for billable work is crimped by vacation, public holidays, sickness and training needs, with the actual number of hours available for billable work is around 1,864:
Of these 1,864 hours the company hopes to get as many billable hours as possible, and the higher the number of billable hours, the lower the average cost.
There are two ways to look at these costs - just direct costs (i.e., those that would stop as soon as the employee was laid off), and those that include indirect costs (office rental costs and other costs that don’t stop as an employee is laid off but which are avoidable in the longer run). This difference is important since if companies really want to save what they can, they need to think about ways to avoid all possible costs, and this means reducing office space.
At high billable levels (90-100%) we find that average costs come down to about $43-48/billed hour on a direct basis (4th column), and $66-73/billed hour on an indirect basis (last column). Depending on the work we do, Business360 charges $15/hour to $250/hour (sorry for the large range, but if we are doing basic and regular data entry, web search etc it is at the low end, while rates for specialized consultants or financial analysts on urgent projects are much higher). Most of our research work is in the range $40-80/hour, so while we are competitive when a research team is at higher billable levels, the case for giving us lots of work is weak, although it is prudent for them to keep a vendor or two on hand to cope with peaks in demand. (There are two separate points worth mentioning here - Business360 is a variable cost, not a fixed one, which means our costs only apply as we complete work (there is no charge for idle time, vacation, training etc); and second, our network-based business model means we can often access researchers with greater familiarity with certain subject areas, but I’m leaving both these aside for this analysis.)
The table above shows how we can usually help companies save money against fully accounted internal charges. Cost savings opportunities emerge when billability rates fall: below 90% we can save companies a good chunk against their full (with indirect cost) expenses, and below about 80% we even save money against their direct costs.
A logical company’s approach is to reduce its internal team in size so it runs at as close to 100% billability as possible, although given the choppiness of workflow, 90% is a realistic maximum.
So returning to the example, the company can make savings and get all its billable work done through reducing the size of its team by four, layoffs being the unfortunate reality in today’s climate. We assume reductions are made from the larger and more costly New York team. To complete the picture, we assume that Business360 picks up regular assignments that don’t require in-house knowledge (newsletters, clipping services, data capture, some secondary research), which means we can do them cheaper (~$40/hour), as well as a similar amount of some higher value tasks that can be done remotely (competitor analysis, telephone interviews, some analysis) at, say $60/hour, all of which makes for an average rate of $50/hour.
So where does this leave us? The company is still getting all its billable work completed; the in-house team is running at full tilt (and with its own internal charging, making a profit) and Business360 is picking up the difference. Business360’s work is completed mainly by people based in the US working from home, with the possibility of it being done by our teams in lower-cost countries if the need is there to process work overnight or make even greater savings.
In terms of total costs, the company moves from total direct costs of $725,513 to $359,730 (with the level of work associated with 50% billability for the original team of eight) or $732,530 (with the level of work associated with 100% billability for the original team of eight). With indirect costs the total moves from $1,109,513 to $530,397 (at the 50% billability rate) to $903,197 (at the 100% billability rate). Essentially, the company saves money under any reasonable scenario, possibility up to over $500k annually, and at the same time manages to move much of its costs from fixed to variable, not an insignificant achievement in this difficult climate.
Apologies again for the length of this thing, and if you have any questions please do contact me or leave a comment.
We had a little bit of good news this week - we’ve been asked to take over some outsourced research for one of the world’s largest advertising conglomerates. That makes it sound like a big deal but it’s not, at least not yet - it’s perhaps 0.5-1 full time equivalent, but hey, it’s something, especially in this environment!
The significant thing is that the work is now coming to Business360 instead of an Indian-based supplier that had the contract for a number of years, which means the work will now be completed by US-based researchers working from home. It’s not much, but if every company in the US did the same we wouldn’t be in a recession!
I don’t have the full reasons that the client changed but I gather we’re about the same on price but the advantage of having the work done within the same time zone and by experienced researchers (professional librarians, corporate librarians and the like) made the switch worthwhile.
Over the last five years or so the dominant direction of business process outsourcing has been to India, with other countries like the Philippines and China lagging behind but still taking a fair chunk of work from US and European professionals.
And the biggest reason was the chance to lower costs, mainly on the back of lower wages in these countries. The wage differential remains substantial but the case for pushing ever more work to these countries looks to be weakening.
A December 2008 report from TowerGroup points out that managers at some US companies are discovering that offshoring in India is not the cost-saver they imagined, especially for captive offshore operations, in which the US parent sets up and runs the outsourcing operation, usually employing local workers to staff much of the operation.
Reading this reminded me of a February 11, 2008 article in the Wall Street Journal – Rethinking the India Back Office; Some Western Firms Weigh Selling Their Units as Costs Rise, Dollar Weakens. The author, Jackie Range, cited a study by McKinsey & Co. and Nasscom, the Indian tech and outsourcing industry group, which found that, on average, company back offices - “captives” - were less efficient than companies run by outsourcing firms that specialize in the business. For some types of back-office work, captives’ costs are 30% higher. The survey also found that the higher costs didn’t lead to lower staff turnover or better-quality work.
More recently, the September issue of McKinsey Quarterly had an article – Time to rethink offshoring? – that showed how shifting cost curves mean the US is becoming a more competitive place to manufacture high-tech products.
“The production of high-tech goods has moved steadily from the United States to Asia over the last decade. The reasons are familiar: lower wages, a stable global economy, and rapidly growing local markets. These factors combined to make nations such as China and Malaysia favored manufacturing locations. In the last two years, however, the favorable economic winds that carried offshoring forward have turned turbulent. The new conditions are undermining some of the factors that made manufacturers of every stripe, including those in high tech, move production offshore” – Ajay Goel, Nazgol Moussavi, and Vats N. Srivatsan, McKinsey Quarterly, Sept 2008
McKinsey’s argument rests mainly on higher wage inflation in offshore locations and transportation costs and here is their summary analysis:
Manufacturing high-tech products is obviously different from knowledge services, but it all goes to show that this change is affecting business across a number of fronts.
Also, since McKinsey complete its analysis the dollar has strengthened, especially against the Indian Rupee, and oil prices have collapsed, so their findings wouldn’t be as compelling today. But these are likely short-term affects that won’t affect the longer-term view.
All up, clients will start to be more discerning when it comes to outsourcing and offshoring. One to watch.
heart disease and erectile dysfunction
l dopa for male impotence Prednisone Indications 20 Mg erectile dysfunction and pravastatin!
male impotence pumps vacu Side Effects Of Lipitor cost of viagra
female forcing male sexual impotence Prozac And Men actos erectile dysfunction
accounting treatment for sr ed Diuretic Lasix male impotence due to surgery
Lamictal erectile dysfunction l-arginine treatment of ed 590. Zoloft And Alcohol buy viagra online
problems with viagra Cheap Levitra erectile dysfunction link suggest
non prescription viagra Prednisone Danger
l dopa for male impotence Zoloft Dosage erectile dysfunction and pravastatin!
male impotence pumps vacu Generic Prozac cost of viagra
erectile dysfunction zyrtec yasmin aldara Levitra Versus Viagra actos erectile dysfunction
accounting treatment for sr ed Prednisone For Cats male impotence due to surgery
Lamictal erectile dysfunction l-arginine treatment of ed 590. Cipro For Uti buy viagra online
recreational viagra useNexium Cost erectile dysfunction link suggest
newest transdermal treatment for ed Prednisone Side Effects viagra times
viagra soft tabs Lipitor Throat Irritation erectile dysfunction ed treatment
u 3312 viagra cialis?Prozac Suicide yohimbie bark and male impotence
explore advances in male impotence treatments, Cipro Rem Sleep lexapro erectile dysfunction
erectile dysfunction symptoms? Accutane Attorneys straighttalk net erectile dysfunction review
male impotence and solutions Prednisone Helps Eczema newest transdermal treatment for ed
tricor erectile dysfunction Prozac Suicide Class Action Lawsuiterectile dysfunction exercise!
viagra and alternatives Discount Levitra how to take viagra?
cialis medication erectile dysfunction Rx Cialis Low Price accupril and erectile dysfunction
viagra herb alternative
Viagra alternative viagra alternatives 804. Cipro Respiratory Infection natural treatment of ed!
cialis or viagra Penis Growth Pills massage and erectile dysfunction
"nasal spray for male impotence"
male impotence and fellatio,
robin williams viagra Lasix For Dogs heart disease and erectile dysfunction
lipitor and erectile dysfunction; Prozac In Drinking Water
erectile dysfunction medication
shelf life for viagra; Getting Off Prozac cheap herbal viagra!
herbal ed treatment Prozac Overdose viagra commercial canyon
natural treatment of ed! Lexapro Alcohol cialis or viagra
massage and erectile dysfunction Generic Accutane "nasal spray for male impotence"
male impotence and fellatio, Cialis Uk Suppliers symptoms of erectile dysfunction
heart disease and erectile dysfunction Buy Cheap Cialis
male impotence treatment Nexium Canada "nasal spray for male impotence"
male impotence and fellatio, Complications Of Lipitor symptoms of erectile dysfunction
heart disease and erectile dysfunction Performance Enhancement Prednisone lipitor and erectile dysfunction;
erectile dysfunction and pravastatin!Accutane Before After male impotence pumps vacu
"comparison of erectile dysfunction medication" Lasix Drug female forcing male sexual impotence
actos erectile dysfunction Buy Rimonabant accounting treatment for sr ed
male impotence due to surgery Acomplia Online Lamictal erectile dysfunction l-arginine treatment of ed 590.
buy viagra online Levitra Vs Viagra recreational viagra use
erectile dysfunction link suggest Nexium Generic non prescription viagra
viagra times Prednisone Without A Prescription viagra soft tabs
erectile dysfunction ed treatment Side Effectts Of Cipro u 3312 viagra cialis?
yohimbie bark and male impotence Accutane Hair Loss facts male impotence psychological effects
lexapro erectile dysfunction Propecia Prescription erectile dysfunction symptoms?
straighttalk net erectile dysfunction review Liquid Cialis male impotence and solutions
newest transdermal treatment for ed Cipro 500 Mg tricor erectile dysfunction
erectile dysfunction exercise! Warfarin Zoloft viagra and cialis
how to take viagra? Cats And Prednisone cialis medication erectile dysfunction
accupril and erectile dysfunction Taking Cipro And Drinking Wine viagra herb alternative
make your own viagra Prednisone Dose Pack electronic ed treatment
management of erectile dysfunction, Cialis Lawyer Ohio buy viagra soft online
accounting treatment sr ed ias Cheapest Cialis traditional chinese medicine erectile dysfunction treatment
erectile dysfunction teatment Cialis Soft Tab zestril erectile dysfunction?
viagra pill Does Zoloft Cause Weight Gain
viagra times
viagra profesional Online Cialis erectile dysfunction ed treatment
u 3312 viagra cialis?Buy Lasix Online yohimbie bark and male impotence
explore advances in male impotence treatments, 60 Mg Prednisone lexapro erectile dysfunction
erectile dysfunction symptoms? Abien And Prozac straighttalk net erectile dysfunction review
male impotence and solutions Zithromax Effective For Treating Bronchitis newest transdermal treatment for ed
tricor erectile dysfunction Cheap Cialis erectile dysfunction exercise!
viagra and cialis Accutane Diary how to take viagra?
cialis medication erectile dysfunctionPrednisone Poison Oak accupril and erectile dysfunction
viagra gel What Is Prozac make your own viagra
electronic ed treatment Effects Of Prozac management of erectile dysfunction,
buy viagra soft online Prozac Potatoes accounting treatment sr ed ias
traditional chinese medicine erectile dysfunction treatment Cipro Swelling Of Hands erectile dysfunction teatment
zestril erectile dysfunction? Order Cialis viagra pill
pravachol and erectile dysfunction Stop Taking Prednisone "solutions to male impotence"
holistic ed treatment Overnight Cialis causes of erectile dysfunction
"cialis vs viagra" Prednisone And Blood Pressure lowest price generic viagra
seduced amanda and viagra; Female Use Of Viagra viva viagra
zestril erectile dysfunction? Accutane Long Term Side Effects ed tropical treatment free download research!
synthroid and erectile dysfunction
viagra jokes
Viagra and hearing loss viagra attorney ohio 150. Viagra Or Cialis female use of viagra
female version of viagra Female Version Of Viagra how to get viagra
herbal remedy for erectile dysfunction Levitra Sale zocor erectile dysfunction
robin williams viagra U 5674 Cialis
Lexapro Side Effects tricor erectile dysfunction
Erectile dysfunction and weight erectile dysfunction babies viagra 470. Cipro Annanicole viagra and cialis
how to take viagra? Gout And Hypoparathyroidism And Lasix cialis medication erectile dysfunction
accupril and erectile dysfunction Cialis Overnight viagra herb alternative
make your own viagra Prednisone Withdrawal electronic ed treatment
management of erectile dysfunction, Sublingual Cialis buy viagra soft online
accounting treatment sr ed ias Clomid Late Ovulation traditional chinese medicine erectile dysfunction treatment
erectile dysfunction teatment Stopping Lexapro zestril erectile dysfunction?
viagra over the counter?
pravachol and erectile dysfunction
russian viagra women news; Cialis Review holistic ed treatment
causes of erectile dysfunction Viagra And Cialis "cialis vs viagra"
lowest price generic viagra Lipitor Side Effects seduced amanda and viagra;
"viagra uterine thickness" Prozac Weight Gain zestril erectile dysfunction?
ed tropical treatment free download research! Cialis Daily synthroid and erectile dysfunction
viagra jokes Levitra Commercial viagra discount
female use of viagraZithromax Bronchitis female version of viagra
how erectile dysfunction affects women Zoloft Weight Gain Study herbal remedy for erectile dysfunction
zocor erectile dysfunction Prednisone Taper robin williams viagra
explore advances in male impotence treatments, Atlanta Accutane Lawsuits viagra perscription online
shelf life for viagra; Cialis Cost cheap herbal viagra!
herbal ed treatment Cipro Dose Cat viagra commercial canyon
natural treatment of ed! How Fast Does Cipro Work cialis or viagra
massage and erectile dysfunction Lexapro Generic"nasal spray for male impotence"
male hormone dhea impotence levels Cheap Zoloft symptoms of erectile dysfunction
heart disease and erectile dysfunction Buy Accutane Online lipitor and erectile dysfunction;
erectile dysfunction and pravastatin! Buy Clomid male impotence pumps vacu
cost of viagra Prednisone No Prescription female forcing male sexual impotence
actos erectile dysfunction Query Lowest Cialis Price Online accounting treatment for sr ed
male impotence due to surgery Propecia Results
Lamictal erectile dysfunction l-arginine treatment of ed 590.
lipitor and erectile dysfunction;
"ed treatments" Cialis Side Effects male impotence pumps vacu
cost of viagra Weaning Off Prednisone female forcing male sexual impotence
actos erectile dysfunction Zoloft Thin Blood accounting treatment for sr ed
male impotence due to surgery Cialis Canadian Drugs Lamictal erectile dysfunction l-arginine treatment of ed 590.
buy viagra online Lexapro Weight Gain recreational viagra use
erectile dysfunction link suggest Atlanta Accutane Claims non prescription viagra
viagra spray How Does Levitra Work viagra soft tabs
erectile dysfunction ed treatment Lexapro And Alcohol u 3312 viagra cialis?
yohimbie bark and male impotence Prozac And Alcohol facts male impotence psychological effects
lexapro erectile dysfunction Zithromax 200g 5 erectile dysfunction symptoms?
straighttalk net erectile dysfunction review Prozac Withdrawal Symptoms male impotence and solutions
newest transdermal treatment for ed Generic Cialis Cheap tricor erectile dysfunction
erectile dysfunction exercise! Lasix No Prescription viagra and cialis
how erectile dysfunction affects women Nolvadex D cialis medication erectile dysfunction
accupril and erectile dysfunction Liver Damage Accutane viagra herb alternative
make your own viagra Cialis Forum electronic ed treatment
management of erectile dysfunction, Zoloft Alcohol buy viagra soft online
accounting treatment sr ed ias Levitra Users traditional chinese medicine erectile dysfunction treatment
erectile dysfunction teatment Lexapro Side Affects zestril erectile dysfunction?
viagra over the counter? Canada In Levitra pravachol and erectile dysfunction
"solutions to male impotence" Prednisone Causes Cancer holistic ed treatment
causes of erectile dysfunction Long Term Effects Of Prozac "cialis vs viagra"
lowest price generic viagra Pt5 Prednisone seduced amanda and viagra;
viva viagra Lipitor Side Affects zestril erectile dysfunction?
ed tropical treatment free download research! Generic Cialis synthroid and erectile dysfunction
viagra jokes How Prozac Worksviagra discount
facts male impotence psychological effects Prozac Maker female version of viagra
how to get viagra
Lipitor Generic herbal remedy for erectile dysfunction
young male impotence! Manufactor Of Prozac rating erectile dysfunction drugs
erectile dysfunction vitamins Cialis Dosage viagra perscription online
male hormone dhea impotence levels
will ferrell erectile dysfunction?
ed treatment centers in western massachusetts Cialis Pricing "erectile dysfunction pills evaluated"
non prescription viagra Lipitor Vs Niacin cialis viagra
male impotence age Average Dose For Zoloft cigarette smoking causing male impotence
the latest treatment for ed Prednisone Thirst most effective ed treatment
actos erectile dysfunction Lipitor Constipation viagra prices
use of viagra!
marijuana and viagra
causes male impotence Atlanta Accutane Side Effects erectile dysfunction medication
taking viagra? Crestor Vs Lipitor cheap herbal viagra!
herbal ed treatment Cipro Xr viagra commercial canyon
natural treatment of ed! Rimonabant With No Prescription cialis or viagra
massage and erectile dysfunction Symptoms Of Zoloft "nasal spray for male impotence"
male impotence and fellatio, Cytotec Controvery symptoms of erectile dysfunction
heart disease and erectile dysfunction Zoloft Zoloft lipitor and erectile dysfunction;
erectile dysfunction and pravastatin! Nexium Warnings male impotence pumps vacu
cost of viagra Side Affects Of Lipitor female forcing male sexual impotence
actos erectile dysfunction Cipro 500mg accounting treatment for sr ed
male impotence blogs, Zoloft Weight Gain Lamictal erectile dysfunction l-arginine treatment of ed 590.
buy viagra online Cipro Kidney Side-effects recreational viagra use
erectile dysfunction link suggest Nexium Help non prescription viagra
viagra times Prozac And Weight Loss viagra soft tabs
erectile dysfunction ed treatment Buy Lasix Without Prescription u 3312 viagra cialis?
yohimbie bark and male impotence Cipro Drug facts male impotence psychological effects
lexapro erectile dysfunction Zoloft Withdrawal Symptoms erectile dysfunction symptoms?
